Skip to main content

Missed games are rapidly lowering Aaron Nesmith's trade value

Good player, decent contract, if he plays
ByThilo Widder
Oct 28, 2026; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA;  Indiana Pacers guard Aaron Nesmith (23) in the first half against the Philadelphia 76ers at Gainbridge Fieldhouse.  Mandatory Credit: Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images
Oct 28, 2026; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Indiana Pacers guard Aaron Nesmith (23) in the first half against the Philadelphia 76ers at Gainbridge Fieldhouse. Mandatory Credit: Trevor Ruszkowski-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Aaron Nesmith is the quintessential Indiana Pacer. He was ignored and discarded by a big-name organization and was widely considered a draft bust before his arrival in Indiana. Since he's gotten here, however, he has been an excellent player and one of the best three-and-D wings in all of basketball...

When he plays.

That proviso has been harder and harder to fill over the past two years, when Nesmith played just 45 games each season. That may be hard to remember, as he was so important for that Finals run in 2024-25, but Nesmith's durability has been in question for a while now.

As the saying goes, fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me; fool me three times, and that's a trend we need to keep track of.

No one is doubting how good Nesmith is at this point. But with the team already dealing with so many injury concerns, it might soon be time to move on from a player who just can't seem to stay on the court.

With the Pacers already reportedly looking at different options in the wing market, it's safe to assume they are starting to move on from the Vanderbilt product.

Physicality hurt Nesmith more than it helped

Shot creation is such an important thing in the NBA. Over the years, it has grown from something that only the stars were expected to do to a skill that even role players need to have. However, while adding that ability usually helps a role player ascend from the bench to a starting spot or even further, it hasn't helped Aaron Nesmith.

Let's not be overly simplistic. Nesmith grew as a player when he arrived in Indiana because his shooting is far better on the break than it was in the half-court sets he ran as a Boston Celtic. The Pacers' system was a far better fit than that of the Celtics.

The improvements are also on an individual scale. Nesmith played better with more opportunity and more chances to fail freely.

No, the big difference is the physicality in getting to the free-throw line and attacking the rim, which is something Nesmith added to his game at the same time that he started missing games.

It's hard to say that becoming a better, more well-rounded player might ultimately be what ends Nesmith's time in Indiana, but it's hard to continue investing in a player who just can't stay healthy.


Check out the FanSided App!

The FanSided app is free on iPhone and Android. Download it, choose "Indiana Pacers," and add the other teams and interests you follow to build your feed. 

You can use the app without an account. Create a free account in the app before Dec. 31 to receive the limited-edition Founding Fan badge on your profile, which unlocks future perks. 

Download the app here, and we'll see you over there! Go 'Cers!

Add us as a preferred source on Google