Skip to main content

It may be time to admit that the Pacers are just not a good team

Can we be honest for a moment?
ByThilo Widder
Nov 20, 2026; Cleveland, Ohio, USA;  Indiana Pacers head coach Rick Carlisle reacts after calling a time out during the second half against the Cleveland Cavaliers at Rocket Arena.  Mandatory Credit: David Dermer-Imagn Images
Nov 20, 2026; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Indiana Pacers head coach Rick Carlisle reacts after calling a time out during the second half against the Cleveland Cavaliers at Rocket Arena. Mandatory Credit: David Dermer-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Pessimism in the NBA is a sad, sad thing. Basketball is such a joyous hobby for all of us, and yet it feels so inescapable to find the games so miserable when your team fails to perform at the level you would expect.

Last year's gap season for the Indiana Pacers felt understandable and, as such, more digestible. This one does not feel at all like that. The Pacers are 5-11 and have been without the star that carried so much of the weight of the hope that people had for a resurgent season.

While injury excuses may be fair, it's hard to look at this team turning things around up to the standard that people may have held them to in the offseason. It may feel like the fastest solution is to simply puff out your chest and to claim that everything is going to work out, but the unfortunate truth is that this may just not be a very good team.

The Pacers have gone on runs before, and they very well could do that, but it feels like anyone who's expecting a top-four seed in the Eastern Conference needs to temper their expectations quite a bit.

What would a good Pacers season even look like?

Would it be enough for Tyrese Haliburton to come back and play at a high enough level to earn an All-Star nod? Would it be enough for the Pacers simply to make it out of the lottery and to lose in the playoffs? Would anything but a title be enough?

Hopefully, the answer is yes, because it doesn't feel like this team can go much further than that second option right now. Putting all of the weight of this team's success on Haliburton's return feels woefully unfair to the guy who was supposed to have more help than he ever has.

Instead, he will need to play hero ball to get Indiana back in the race in an incredibly deep Eastern Conference. It's not to say that that's impossible for him, just that it may not be incredibly cognizant of the recent injury troubles he has had.

The larger issue, though, is that this team is coming up on a ton of incredibly complicated and difficult contract questions next summer, when half of their team will be looking for extensions. Maybe it's time to admit that the franchise that everyone thought could work their way back has a much harder path forward than anyone could have expected.


Indiana Pacers basketball lives on the FanSided App

The FanSided app is free on iPhone and Android. Download it, choose "Indiana Pacers," and add the other teams and interests you follow to build your feed. 

You can use the app without an account. Create a free account in the app before Dec. 31 to receive the limited-edition Founding Fan badge on your profile, which unlocks future perks. 

Download the app here, and we'll see you over there! Go 'Cers!

Add us as a preferred source on Google